Adult-FanFiction.org : Cartoons

New Year's Game Night III	By : Lennox Category: +S through Z > Simpsons Views: 16878 -:- Recommendations : 3 -:- Currently Reading : 3
Disclaimer: I do not own The Simpsons. The characters are the property of 20th Century Fox and I am not associated with the owners of the show. This story is a work of fan-fiction, was written for entertainment purposes, and is not intended for profit.

Chapter List
- 1
- 2
- 3
Chapter 1
"Janey!" Lisa cried in surprise. She was the last person that she expected to see. "What... what are you doing here?" Lisa reflexively reached up to fiddle with her pearl necklace before she realised that she wasn't wearing it.
"Come on Lisa, you know me." Janey grinned as Jessica pulled her coat from her arms. "I saw you guys all go into the mayor's office last year, and I assumed that it was some private party. But my Mom wouldn't let me follow you guys to see what was going on. So asked Jessica and here I am." Lisa nervously chuckled as Jessica placed Janey's coat with the others on the final row of pews.
"So what are we doing? Partying? Dancing? Are there any more boys coming?" Janey asked her final question after seeing Bart, Milhouse, Nelson and Colin. She stepped toward the Irish boy.
"I don't think we've met before." she said, her arm outstretched. With a smile, Colin took her hand and shook it.
"I'm Colin. I'm an old friend of Lisa's"
"Oh my gosh," Janey almost quivered, "I love that accent." Lisa, grateful for the distraction, ducked out to ambush Jessica as she returned from the coats.
"What the hell do you think you're doing?" she demanded in a hushed voice as she grabbed Jessica's arm and pulled her aside. "You didn't think to ask us about inviting someone else to a game like this?"
"Lisa, relax. It's okay." Jessica tried to calm her down as she pulled her arm from Lisa's grasp.
"Okay? How is it going to be okay? I don't want Janey to find out about me and Bart. The first dare we get is all it' going take for her to tell everyone on the first day back of school."
"Well, you just 'invited' Colin to join us last year without asking." Jessica said, trying to prove her actions.
"Colin saw us." Lisa hissed. "He came up to me with my panties in his hand..."
"If you don't wear them, you can't leave them lying around." Jessica smirked.
"... and he promised to keep our secret." Lisa continued, ignoring the interruption.
"Look, Lisa. Janey doesn't know anything about what we've done. And I've told her that whatever goes on here will stay here. But, if you're really uncomfortable with her being here, I'll ask her to leave." Jessica had her hands on Lisa's shoulders, while Lisa rubbed her forehead with her fingers. She sighed as she admitted defeat.
"No. Now that she's here and knows something is going on, she'll want to stay. You'll never get her to leave." She knew Janey all too well.
"Well, look at it this way Lis. She probably will find out about you and Bart. I mean, Laura did and she turned out to be trustworthy enough, even though I think she had her own reasons for last year. Anyway, you could always give Janey a dare to get some leverage over her. I've already thought of one or two things to ensure her silence."
"You two okay over there?" Janey called from the other end of the church. Jessica flashed her a thumbs up before she turned back to Lisa.
"Look, I'm sorry I didn't tell you about this. It just never crossed my mind. But I want to make this right by you." Jessica met Lisa's gaze, her eyes looking straight into her friend's. "Whatever happens tonight, just know that I've got your back." Jessica stepped to Lisa's side, gently placing her hand on the girl's ass, a gesture that went unseen from the others behind the rows of pews.
"Okay..." she sighed, allowing a few seconds to compose herself. "Thanks, Jessica."
"And besides," Jessica grinned as she slowly licked her lips, "you know I can make it up to you later." Her tongue finished its travels around her mouth with a wink from Jessica's eye and Lisa felt a slight blush across her cheeks.
"You'd better." Lisa chuckled. She meant it as a joke, but Jessica was dead serious.
"First break we get. You and me. My dad's office." Jessica winked at her again, before she turned and walked down the aisle towards the others.
*****
"Truth or Dare? Isn't this a bit childish?" Janey asked as she sat on the floor. Jessica just scoffed at the comment.
"It can be more fun than you think." Jessica smiled. "Now, who needs a recap on the rules?" The children had taken their seats on the floor in a circle by the alter towards the back of the church. The empty Duff Beer bottle sat in front of them on its side and the freshly unwrapped 'extra naughty' decks of Truth or Dare cards lay on the floor beside it, divided into Truth, Dare and Penalty piles.
"You sure you haven't looked at those, Jessica?" Lisa asked, jokingly. Jessica raised one hand into the air and drew an X over her chest with the other.
"Cross my heart, Lisa." The girl smiled.
"So, we're not asking our own?" Janey asked as she pointed at the decks of cards. "We have to use those?"
"You can if you want," Jessica began. "You use the cards if you can't think of anything, or if you want to make it more fun. But sometimes they have group dares and truths as well."
"So what are the rules?" Janey asked.
"Rules are simple, Janey. Seeing as this is your first time, you can start. You spin the bottle and ask Truth or Dare to whomever it points to. If they turn down truth, you give them a dare. If they turn down a dare, they take a Penalty card."
"What if that person can't do what it says on the card?" Janey interrupted.
"If someone is physically unable to perform their dare, for whatever the reason, then you just use the next card." Jessica began to count off the remaining rules on her fingers. "You can't pick truth more than twice in a row unless it's a group truth. You can't ask any follow-up questions on truth once the person has answered. If the bottle stops between two people then it's a group truth or dare with the spinner's choice."
"What if... say, Milhouse needs Allison to perform his dare, but Allison refuses?" Janey asked.
"Then she'd take the penalty, not Milhouse. She's the one preventing the dare being carried out. And above all else, whatever happens in this game stays with us. We don't talk about what we do or say outside of tonight."
"I think I got it." Janey said as she ran the rules through her head once again. "Or is this the type of game that adds new rules as we go along?"
"It's happened before," Bart said. "But we usually all agree on it first." Janey nodded as she reached forward to place her hand on the bottle.
"So, I'm first?" she asked. Jessica nodded. With a flick of her wrist, Janey spun the bottle. It circled around the group at an impressive speed, and all eyes were locked on the glass container as it slowly came to a stop in front of the game's first chosen participant.

'Perfect.' Jessica thought as the bottle came to a stop in front of her. She sat cross legged on the floor, the bottle pointing directly at her bare slit, hidden under her dress.
"So what's it going to be Jessica? Truth, or Dare?" Janey asked, trying to sound suspenseful.
"Janey, you're going to learn quickly that I almost never pick truth."
"So dare?" Janey said.
"Is there another option?"
"Alright Jessica, I dare you to.... to..." Janey suddenly realised that she had nothing. She was so keen to start with the first spin and yet she was stumped when it came time to give Jessica a challenge.
"Um..."
"Use the cards. That's what they're there for." Jessica said. It took every ounce of self control for her to appear calm and collected. Every day since the cards had arrived, she'd left them out on her desk to tease herself. They had sat in plain view for weeks, silently taunting her with the secretive pleasures that were hidden inside the plastic wrapping. She wanted to look, if nothing else to welcome her punishment at the hands of Lisa. But her promise to the girl was stronger than her curiosity. And, now that Janey was stumped, she could finally get her first taste of these new suggestions. Jessica bit her bottom lip as her heart pounded in her chest. She watched as Janey reached for the pile of Dare cards and her fingers grasped the one on top. It seemed to take forever for her to lift it to her face and read from its surface. But as Janey's eyes darted over the words, her face fell into shock and horror.
"Jessica..."
"Yes?" she asked. "Read it out. Don't be shy."
"Is this... what are these? Are you serious?" Janey asked, reading the card again in disbelief. Jessica looked straight into the girl's eyes.
"Absolutely. This is what we did in the mayor's office last year. Now read it out."
"You have to... demonstrate your favourite sexual position with the person on your left." Allison felt herself blush a little. She was used to Jessica's sexual escapades and always looked forward to exploring more with her. Jessica brought her fingers to her chin, ignoring the look of confusion and discomfort on Janey's face as she pondered her challenge.
"Hmmm, let's see now." She rolled herself onto her knees and gently pushed Allison towards the floor. "Alli and I did this one on Halloween and I enjoyed it." Jessica rolled Allison onto her side, lifted her leg to place it over her shoulder and pressed her crotch against the brunette's. Jessica's skirt rode up over her hips and thighs, but her bare pussy remained obscured from view as she recreated rubbing their pussies together.
"And I guess this one is nice when there's a dick involved," Jessica rolled Allison onto her back and sat on her crotch.
"But I think this one is my favourite position." Jessica winked at Allison as she climbed off her, and lifted her legs to place them over her shoulders once again. She buried her face into Allison's crotch, lifting her dress with only her panties to cover the bald yellow slit. Jessica took this moment to steal a quick lick, pressing the fabric of the girl's panties against her folds with her moist tongue. A sharp yet soft gasp escaped Allison's lips as she felt the sudden need to have Jessica's tongue inside her once again.
"Yeah," Jessica said as she sat back up. "Definitely my favourite."
"WHAT THE HELL KIND OF GAME IS THIS?" Janey asked, her eyes wide in disbelief at the sight she had just seen.
"A fun one." Jessica grinned as she reached forward to spin the bottle. "You'll learn to love it before long."

The bottle came to a stop in front of Milhouse. The blue-haired boy gulped. Like everyone else, he too was looking forward to the sexual escapades, but would rather avoid the resulting humiliation from his turn.
"What's it going to be Milhouse?" Jessica asked as she smiled at him. "You going to get your first dare out of the way? Or are you going to pussy out and pick truth instead?" Milhouse had taken time to reflect on previous years. His secret foot fetish had been exposed and indulged on two separate occasions. And he had received a blowjob from his best friend. Compared to the others, he had gotten off relatively lightly so far. But his easy streak on Jessica's game couldn't last forever. Trying his best to keep his nerves from showing, Milhouse gulped again.
"Dare." He said. "I'm not trying to get out of anything." Not even he believed the fake confidence he was trying to convey. But at least if Jessica did have something embarrassing in mind for him, he at least had a chance to make it worse for the next person.
"Let's break the ice for you, Milhouse. Maybe build up your confidence a bit. I dare you to go around the circle, and kiss every girl on the lips."
"What?" Lisa and Janey both asked.
"That's the dare." Jessica shrugged. "You don't want him to do it? Then you take the penalty."
"I think I'd rather risk it." Janey muttered under her breath, but her words did not escape Jessica's ears. Without looking, she placed the first Penalty card on the floor and pushed it towards Janey.
"Are you sure? This game is all about a little embarrassment, but it's called the adult version for a reason." Janey looked at the card on the floor, held under Jessica's fingertips. She had only read one card, and couldn't deny that she was slightly curious about what the rest of the deck would bring. But that curiosity wasn't enough to bring her to risk it.
"Fine," she grumbled as she folded her arms. Carefully, Jessica placed the card back atop the pile and Milhouse made his first move towards Jessica. The reverend's daughter grabbed the side of his face as Milhouse's lips touched hers and she forced her tongue into his mouth the moment they connected. Jessica ran her hands through the hair on the back of his head and his glasses slipped down the bridge of his nose. But as soon as Milhouse placed his hands on Jessica's sides, she broke the kiss and pulled away. It had finished almost as quickly as it started and Jessica smiled at him as if nothing had happened. Milhouse straightened his glasses and turned to Allison. She wasn't as enthusiastic as Jessica, but she didn't deny him a soft and lingering kiss on his lips. When he turned to Lisa, she just rolled her eyes.
"I never thought I'd be doing this again after you caught me spying on you with that fifth grade girl. What was her name? Louise? Mabel?"
"Her name was Taffy! And I still think she was the best thing that ever happened to me!" Milhouse almost snapped at Lisa, as if there was some forgotten anger still bottled up inside him after that night at Holding Hands Point. He grabbed Lisa's shoulders in his hands and placed a quick yet firm kiss on her mouth before he moved to Janey.
"Milhouse, I'm not sure..." the young girl began as she stood up.
"Trust me Janey, you don't want to take a Penalty card." Before Janey could react, he quickly planted his lips on hers and took his seat. Janey remained standing, quickly realising that she'd just had her first kiss.
"Yo, Janey. You okay?" Bart asked, bringing her out of her thoughts. A soft blush formed on her cheeks as she sat back down. Without another word, Milhouse spun the bottle.

"I'll take truth, Milhouse." Nelson said as he sat cross-legged and hunched over. He had been dreading his turn since the game started. Despite his relationship with Bart and Milhouse improving in recent years, he was still concerned that they'd use this opportunity to take some sort of revenge on his bullying. At least with truth, he didn't have to do anything embarrassing.
"What is your deepest, darkest fantasy, Nelson?"
"A fantasy is something you want to do, right?" Nelson asked.
"In a sense, yes." Lisa said.
"Well, I've already done mine. Next!" Nelson said as he reached for the bottle, but Milhouse reached forward and grabbed Nelson's wrist. He suddenly realised the position he'd put himself in, grabbing the bully who had tormented him for years. But he didn't back down.
"No, Nelson. I didn't ask you if you had done it. I asked you what it was."
"Fine!" Nelson blustered as he pulled his arm from Milhouse's grasp. Nelson swore at himself under his breath as, in his haste to get out of divulging his fantasy, he had already confessed to doing it.
"It was... it was to sleep with an older woman." he admitted.
"And you've done it? Who was it?" Bart asked.
"Your mom." Nelson grunted as he spun the bottle. "No follow-up questions, remember?" He folded his arms, refusing to lift his head and look at anyone in the eye. He just watched the bottle and waited for it to stop, hoping that this wouldn't come up again.

"Janey, you're up!" Jessica smiled as she clasped and rubbed her hands together. She couldn't deny how much she had been looking forward to the girl's first turn.
"Truth or Dare, Janey?" Nelson asked. Janey bit her bottom lip. So far she had seen Jessica use Allison to show off her favourite sexual positions, watched Milhouse kiss every girl, and listened to Nelson admit his fantasy. She always pictured Truth or Dare to be a lot more... childish. Janey's weakness had always been the need to feel accepted and she often found herself going along with what the 'cool' kids were doing. If she left now, she felt it could damage her reputation and everyone's opinions of her.
"Janey?" Colin asked.
"Fine, okay. I'll take dare." As soon as she said it, she instantly wished she picked truth.
"Let's make this simple. You have to strip naked and run around the room."
"WHAT? NO WAY!" Janey cried. "I'm not going to do that. Lisa, help me out here." Janey turned toward her friend, but Lisa didn't look at her. She just couldn't bring herself to meet her friend's gaze.
"Lisa, don't tell me you agree with them? What if it was you who had to do this?"
"You'd be surprised at some of the things Lisa's had to do in this game." Bart grinned, as he placed his arm around his sister, but Lisa just shrugged him off. The gesture, and her attitude towards Janey did not go unnoticed by Jessica.
"What's it going to be, Janey? You going to take the dare or a penalty?" Allison asked. Janey's eyes switched between Nelson and the Penalty pile. Nelson's dare was mild, but embarrassing. But, from what Jessica had told her, that top card could have her do anything.
"Okay, alright. I'll do the dare." Janey said as she stood up and used the toe of one shoe to lift her heel out of the other.
"You seem nervous, Janey. Want me to do it with you?" Jessica asked as she stood up. "It might make it a bit easier."
"What? No!" Janey exclaimed. "Definitely not."
"Suit yourself." She shrugged as she sat back down.
"I can put my clothes back on when I'm done, right?"
"Sure. If you want to, I mean." Nelson said. Janey sighed as she switched between legs to stand, peeling her other shoe and her socks from her feet. She turned her back to the group and paused, taking a deep breath, before she lifted her dress over her head.
'I can't believe I'm doing this. I can't believe I am doing this.' Janey thought to herself over and over. She paused again as she hooked her fingers into the waistband of her panties. She took another deep breath and slid them down her legs. As soon as they hit the floor, Janey took off. She ran towards the wall on the right side of the altar, her friends only getting a view of her butt as she ran. Janey thought she'd be terrified and yet, as she made her way around the pews, she couldn't deny the thrill that she felt. This was a house of God, a place of holy worship. And here she was helping her friends to desecrate it with her sinful actions. It was exhilarating, but it didn't make it any less embarrassing. She heard cheers and whistles coming from the other side of the room, and Janey quickly covered herself as she turned the third corner. With her hand between her legs and her arm over her chest, she ran to her friends. As quickly as she could, and facing away from everyone, she slipped her feet into the holes in her panties and pulled them up her legs.
"Enjoy that?" Jessica asked as Janey slipped her dress over her head. She didn't answer her. She took her seat and spun the bottle.

"Allison, Truth or Dare?" Janey asked.
"Truth," she replied almost straight away. After her demonstrations with Jessica, Allison was looking forward to another challenge. But at the same time, she didn't want to seem too eager.
"Um... okay." Janey said. Once again, she found herself stumped, but decided to draw from her own dare.
"Have you ever been naked in public? And when?"
"Last year." Allison said, matter-of-factly. Janey was a little taken aback.
"Re... really?" She asked in disbelief. Allison nodded.
"Yep. This one," she said as she pointed at Nelson, "dared me to go around the town square and hide my clothes amongst the party last year. All while this one," Allison dropped one hand and raised the other to point at Jessica, "controlled a vibrating egg inside me."
"And you loved every second of it, didn't you?" Jessica asked, leaning over to give Allison a kiss on her cheek.
"No follow ups." Allison grinned at Jessica, before she reached forward and spun the bottle.

"Yes!" Jessica hissed with excitement as the bottle came to a stop on her.
"Jessica again?" Bart groaned, rolling his eyes with a smile.
"Maybe she's rigged it." Colin joked, playfully nudging Bart with his elbow. Jessica propped herself on one hand, putting all her weight to lean on her arm, as she ran her hair behind her ear with the other.
"How about we really get this party started?" She reached across herself to place her hand on Allison's knee. "Give me a dare Allison and make it a good one."
"You want a dare, Jess? How about we see what Janey could have done." Allison reached forward and took the top card from the Penalty pile. A grin crossed her lips as she read it.
"Jessica, you have to finger yourself to orgasm in front of everyone and you must lick your fingers when you're done."
"Does... does it really say that?" Janey asked, terrified as she remembered how close she came to being given that card. Allison nodded and held it up for everyone to see. But the one person who didn't question it was Jessica. She stood on her knees as she sucked her fingers into her mouth, moistening them with her saliva. Those soaked fingers travelled down her body and underneath her skirt. Jessica leaned forward and got onto her remaining hand and knees. A soft gasp escaped her lips as she felt two fingers penetrate her body. She buried them down to her knuckles and rubbed them over her inner walls. Slowly, she began to fuck herself with them. She didn't care that she was being watched by her closest friends. Performing such an act in front of Bart and Lisa alone was enough to excite her. Allison and the others were a bonus. She looked up at Bart as she fingered herself. While he couldn't see anything, he was still grinning from ear to ear. Lisa, however, seemed distracted. She was watching, but Jessica felt that Lisa's gaze seemed to pass right through her. It was almost like she simply wasn't paying attention.

Jessica closed her eyes as she dropped her head. She bit her bottom lip as her fingers flew in and out of her soaked snatch. Her thoughts drifted back to their previous games. Her first kiss with Allison. Using her lips and tongue on everyone. Fucking herself with the bottle. Licking Bart's cum from Lisa's ass. Even the orgy inside her tent on Halloween. She remembered grinding her pussy against Allison's and licking her feet while watching the two Simpson siblings fuck right in front of them. Everyone in the room was watching her and they could almost hear the squelching sounds of her soaked cunt. Unable and unwilling to hold back, Jessica's arm trembled as she reached her orgasm. It took every ounce of strength to keep herself from collapsing on the floor. The girl panted loudly, her hips bucking against her hand. With a loud sigh, Jessica pushed herself up and fell onto her back in her post-orgasmic bliss.
"Jessica?" Allison asked.
"Yeah, I know." Jessica breathed. Slowly, she lifted her arm into the air and guided her fingers to her face. Without pause or hesitation, she happily accepted them into her mouth. Her eyes closed as she swirled her tongue around and between her fingers, licking and tasting her own pleasure. She lifted her other arm, and Allison grabbed her hand to help pull her up.
"Party started?" Allison asked with a chuckle.
"Oh yeah." Jessica smiled. "The party's started."

"Looks like Janey's up again." Jessica said as the bottle came to a stop in front of her.
"Me? Can't you spin again? What about Bart, Lisa or Colin? They haven't had a turn yet." Jessica just shook her head.
"They may never get a turn. So come on, what's it going to be?"
"Well, I've already done a dare, and I'm not sure I even want to know what you've got planned for me to do. So I'm choosing truth."
"Alright." Jessica said. "Just so we know where you stand. Have you had any experience with sex? Are you a virgin?"
"Isn't that a follow-up question?" Janey asked.
"Not if I ask it before you answer." Jessica shrugged. "Once you've answered, your turn is over. Any questions after that are follow-ups, and you don't have to answer them if you don't want to."
"Fine." Janey sighed. "Yes, I'm a virgin, as all girls our age should be. And this, what's happening here," Janey waved her finger around the circle, "is the most experience I've had." Jessica nodded, but she decided it would be best to put Janey's mind at ease.
"Look, Janey, Truth or Dare isn't fun if we have to force you to do it. Everyone here is up for this and we use the Penalty cards to make it interesting. But if you don't want to play, or it makes you feel uncomfortable," Jessica raised her hand to gesture towards the entrance of the church, "then there's the door. We're not going to think less of you if you decide to leave, nor will we try and stop you. But this is what we all have fun doing." Janey looked at the large wooden doors at the opposite of the aisle. Jessica continued. "Just know that if you do stay, then this kind of stuff is going to be expected from you. After all, making people uncomfortable is the idea of the game." Janey didn't say anything for several seconds. She just looked at the large doors, processing what she'd just been told. So far she'd seen her friends do things that would never occur to her. Do things that she knew they were far too young to be doing. Janey hung her head. Before she spoke, Jessica knew her answer.
"I'll stay. Just go easy on me, okay?" Janey's desire to fit in was also her greatest weakness and Jessica knew it. Janey had been invited to a private party in the most unlikely place. If she left now, what would she do? Jessica knew it wouldn't involve her parents.
"Spin up, Janey." Jessica said.

"Finally." Janey sighed as the bottle landed on Bart.
"Give me a dare, Janey. Show me what you've got."
"Alright Bart," Janey suddenly sounded confident as the perfect dare for Bart had popped into her head. Hopefully, it would be one that he'd refuse or at the very least be hesitant about performing. She hoped that this dare would help improve her uncomfortable image.
"Bart, I dare you to kiss your sister!" Bart's scoff was not the response Janey had been hoping for. She didn't expect him to put his arm around Lisa, lift her chin with his fingers and press his lips to her mouth, either. Janey's jaw dropped as she watched the siblings share an open-mouthed kiss. At first, Lisa didn't seem to be into it. Her eyes were closed and she didn't seem to be doing anything. For several seconds, Lisa just seemed to ignore her brother's kiss. Bart was just about to pull back before she decided to return his affections. Lisa placed her hand on the back of Bart's head as her own tongue slipped around his and into his mouth. Without breaking the kiss, she shifted herself onto her knees and pressed herself against her brother. She pushed him back, bumping against Colin as they fell onto the floor. She could feel Bart's shaft grow in his pants under her crotch as her brother's hands wandered under her skirt.
"I reckon I could do you right here, sis." Bart whispered into her ear as he broke their kiss.
"Save it for later. The night's just starting." Lisa whispered back. She gave him one more kiss before she pushed herself up. She lifted one leg over him as she climbed off, offering her hand to pull him back up. Janey's jaw hung where it had dropped.
"So... yeah." Lisa muttered. "Bart and I... yeah." She avoided Janey's gaze. Her pupils would quickly rise to look at her friend before quickly sinking back to the floor. Lisa was inwardly cursing at herself for getting so carried away. Yes, Bart did make the first move on her, but she didn't need to get so involved. Janey was just one more name on the list of people who knew about their secret relationship. And each extra name made Lisa feel less and less comfortable about it.
"Moving on." Bart grinned. He straightened his tie around his neck and reached forward to spin the bottle.

The bottle came to a slow stop in between Janey and Milhouse. She looked at it, puzzled as she lifted her head to face Jessica.
"What does that mean again?"
"Group dare," Jessica grinned. "Or group Truth. Bart's choice."
"Anyone got a coin?" Bart asked.
"I think I do." Colin said as he slipped his hand into his pocket. He pulled out a quarter and tossed it to Bart.
"Heads is truth." He called as he flipped it into the air with his thumb. The silver coin spun as it rose through the air and Bart caught it in his palm when it fell. He placed it on the back of his hand, holding his arm out for the group to see.
"Looks like it's dare." Allison said. "What's it going to be Bart?"
"This card right here." Bart said as he pulled the card from the Dare pile. He read it out loud.
"Okay, so I'll spin the bottle to decide who does this. But whoever it lands on must lie on the floor, and everyone else must press their crotch to that person's face.
"Oh God." Janey groaned as she buried her face in her hands. "Really?"
"Excellent." Jessica grinned. Bart flicked his wrist and the bottle was spun again. All eyes were on the glass container as it finally came to a stop.
"You said... everyone?" Milhouse gulped nervously. Bart held the card up to show him.
"Yep. Everyone. Unless you want to take the penalty for stopping us from doing the dare."
"Fine," he grumbled as he lay on his back. "Just get it over and done with." Jessica lifted the piles of cards and the bottle to place them out of the way atop the altar. But as soon as she placed the Penalty pile down, Lisa drew the top card.
"Well, I'm not putting my crotch over his face." Milhouse swore under his breath. Lisa looked up at Jessica.
"When we first played this and we had to lose our clothes for forfeiting...."
"Same rules, Lisa." Jessica said. "If you're wearing it, it counts as one piece of clothing."
"Looks like I'm removing two pieces then." Lisa placed the card on the altar. As the others lined up over Milhouse, Lisa slipped both of her pink church shoes from her feet. Now in her socks, Lisa sat back down to watch Milhouse's discomfort. One by one, the group would step over Milhouse's head, drop to their knees and press their crotch against his face. Bart, remembering how his face was in Milhouse's crotch two years ago, only gave his friend a couple of seconds. Nelson, however, knelt above his face for a full ten seconds before he stood up. Colin and Janey, like Bart, didn't stay on him for long. Allison, remembering the lick from Jessica, pressed her panty covered slit to his mouth for several seconds. But when Allison stood, Jessica took her place. She looked down at Milhouse and grinned, dropping her bare pussy right onto his mouth.
"Lick it." She whispered. Milhouse hesitated, but soon obeyed. A soft gasp escaped Jessica's lips as she felt the warm wet muscle travel over her folds. She didn't allow his tongue a second swipe. Instead, she stood up and offered her hand to Milhouse.

As he was the victim of the group dare, Milhouse was allowed to take the next spin. The bottle landed on Nelson, who had to remove his underpants and go commando for the rest of the night. In turn, Nelson dared Jessica to make out with him for a full minute. Lisa briefly before choosing truth and, when asked if she had played with her ass before, she blushed and admitted that the only thing that had gone in her ass was her brother's cock and Jessica's tongue. The group watched as Allison performed a striptease down to her underwear and could only be dressed again with help from the others.

After watching a hesitant Milhouse being dared to lick Colin's ear, Jessica checked her phone. They had been playing for just over an hour and Lisa's lack of enthusiasm for the game was starting to irritate her.
"How about we take a break?" she asked as Milhouse placed his hand on the bottle.
"But... but it was my turn." Milhouse protested.
"And it can be your turn afterwards." Jessica said as she got to her feet. "But my ass is going numb and I want to stretch my legs for a bit."
"I guess a rest would be nice." Colin chimed in as he stood up.
"A rest?" Nelson scoffed. "Come on Irish, you've barely done anything this whole game."
"Maybe it's just me four leaf clover and me lucky charms then." Colin sarcastically replied. As Bart stood up, he made his way over to the altar and lifted the lid on the cooler to grab a can of soda. Behind his back, Jessica took Lisa's hand.
"Hey Bart, mind if I borrow your sister for a bit?" she asked him.
"Borrow her?" he asked, curious with Jessica's choice of words. "You could borrow us both if you want, Jess." Even though she expected him to say something like that, she still smirked at his reply.
"Maybe next time, Bart. Girl talk and all. I don't think you'd be interested."
"Jessica, it's you and my sister. I'm very interested." He winked at her.
"Maybe next time." Jessica repeated herself as she pulled Lisa towards the door on the left side of the altar. They slipped through it, and Jessica closed it with a soft thud.

"Where's the bathroom?" Colin asked the remaining kids. Bart pointed to a single wooden door on the other side of the altar, next to the church's confessional booth. Colin made his way towards the door, but froze when he heard a slight bump from inside the tall wooden box.
"Shit!" A hushed voice exclaimed from inside.
"Uh, guys? I think someone's in here." Colin said. The others gathered around him as he reached out to grab the handle. He pulled the door to the confessional box open. A young girl sat on the seat in the small, confined space. She had blonde hair, wore a plain white t-shirt with blue pants, and clutched a video camera close to her chest. Bart and Milhouse stood there in shock, their eyes wide open as they saw the last person they ever expected to see.
"What the hell?" Milhouse asked. "Greta Wolfcastle?"
- 1
- 2
- 3
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

New Year's Game Night III