Adult-FanFiction.org : Cartoons

A New Dawn for Sunset	By : TheEvilFaery Category: +M through R > My Little Pony Views: 4698 -:- Recommendations : 0 -:- Currently Reading : 1
Disclaimer: I do not own My Little Pony, Equestria Girls or any associated characters or properties. I make no money from this story whatsoever.

Chapter List
- 1-A New Dawn for Sunset
- 1
Author's Note: My responses to your (always very, very much appreciated) reviews can be found here: http://www2.adult-fanfiction.org/forum/topic/39000-evil-fairys-review-replies/ (You won't need to register to view the thread.) Thanks as always to Fairy Slayer, for his awesome proofreading & editing skills!
This was originally going to be a multi-part story, but I dragged my feet and by then the second movie had come out and I rather lost interest in the project. So now it stands alone. :)
A New Dawn for Sunset
By The Evil Fairy
In a darkened hallway, Sunset Shimmer fumbled with her keys, her fingers clumsy and slow. Finally, and with a certain amount of quiet cursing, she managed to get the door unlocked. As the door opened, she slumped against it with an exhausted sigh and flicked the lights on.
She surveyed the interior of her small, spotless apartment with a somewhat sour expression. It may have been small, but it was decorated with many flashy, expensive furnishings and trinkets, some from this world, some from Equestria. None of them gained through honest means. Before tonight, she’d thought they gave her home a sort of elegant, royal feel. Now they just looked garish.
“A lot of things look different,” she muttered to herself as she stumbled inside and collapsed onto her expensive leather sofa. She was covered in dust, sweat and bits of cement and masonry, but she was too tired to care. Vice-Principal Luna had put Sunset and her two little henchmen, Snips and Snails, to work repairing the damage they’d done to the school late into the night. Sunset didn’t think she’d ever done so much physical labor in her entire life.
At least when she’d been working she couldn’t think. Now that she could rest, her mind was working overtime. It was over. All of it. Her plans, her revenge, her conquest, all of it gone, snatched out of her hands by Princess Celestia’s newest favorite. No, Twilight had used the Element of Magic while it was sitting right on Sunset’s head. The power had never really been hers. Victory had never been in her hands to start with.
And for the first time in years, Sunset was actually seeing herself. It wasn’t a pretty picture. Petty, spiteful, pointlessly cruel to everyone around her…and why? To try and forget how much she hated herself for throwing everything away? She’d run from Celestia’s instructions because she was convinced there was a better way to more power than the Princess would ever have shown her. Well didn’t that turn out perfectly? Twilight, Celestia’s newest student, was already an alicorn princess, with more power than Sunset had ever even imagined. Sunset was a failure.
And now…what? Twilight had asked her new friends to take care of Sunset before she’d gone back to Equestria, but would they? Could they? Applejack and Rainbow Dash had even helped with the work before it had gotten too late, and they’d spoken to her nicely enough, but…could they really be her friends after everything she’d done? Could anyone be her friend after all that? Could anyone trust her? Or even like her? With a sinking feeling in her stomach, Sunset was forced to admit to herself that she couldn’t imagine it.
She felt like she wanted to cry again, but she was so exhausted that she couldn’t do more than let a tear trickle down her cheek. She knew she should get up and clean herself off, but even as she thought that, sleep rose up and claimed her.
------------------------------
“Sunset Shimmer.” Sunset’s eyes snapped open. She wasn’t lying on her couch anymore! She was somewhere…else. Everything was dark blue and misty. She spun in place on all four hooves, trying to…hooves? Sunset bucked as she looked herself over and realized she was back in her pony form. That must mean she was back in Equestria! But the portal was closed!
“Sunset Shimmer.” Sunset looked up. Some of the white mist in front of her started to thicken and glow. It began to swirl, and then out stepped a white form with a pastel rainbow mane. It was a pony Sunset knew very well.
“P-P-Princess Celestia!” Sunset stammered and backed up. She was suddenly afraid that, despite what Twilight had said, she was about to be punished for her crimes.
“I am so pleased to know you are well, my former student.” Celestia’s voice seemed like it was coming from very far away, but the kindness in the tone was unmistakable, and when she smiled lovingly at the red-maned pony Sunset felt her eyes filling with tears.
“Princess! I’m sorry! I’m so, so sorry! I never should have left you, never!” Sunset sobbed as she threw herself at the princess’ hooves.
“Shhh…hush now,” Celestia said softly as she nuzzled the top of Sunset’s head. “I forgive you. I forgave you the moment you left. I’m only sorry I did not do more to keep you with me. But please listen. My sister is holding a portal open between worlds through the dreamscape, but even she can’t hold it for long. And I have something important to tell you.”
Sunset nodded and wiped her face with her foreleg as she stood up again. “Yes, Princess.”
“I’m offering you a choice, Sunset Shimmer. If you wish, things will remain as they are. You will rebuild your life there. You may doubt that your new friends can truly care for you, but I promise you they will. You may stumble, you may even fall, but they will stay true, and always be there to help you up, as you shall learn to help them. It will be difficult at times, but I believe you will be truly happy.” Celestia paused.
Sunset carefully considered the princess’ words and asked hesitantly, “And…and the other choice?”
“The other choice is a chance to regain what you have lost. To truly learn about the Magic of Friendship. It will be far, far more difficult. You will become my student once again, though we can only speak like this, through the veil of dreams. In time, you may return to Equestria, or perhaps you will choose not to. This world has its own Elements of Harmony, and…” Celestia trailed off and shook her head, her ethereal mane sparkling in the mist. “Where the path ends isn’t important, only whether you choose to place your hoof on its beginning.”
Sunset thought hard, realizing she didn’t have much time to choose. After everything that had happened, did she really want to have anything to do with magic anymore? Couldn’t it just be enough to be a normal girl here, to have friends and be happy? Then she thought of Twilight again. Sunset looked at the ground then up at her teacher. “Princess Celestia, I’ve spent my entire life only thinking of myself. But if I can become your student again, if I can use my magic to help others, instead of just myself. Maybe…maybe then I can really make amends for everything I’ve done.”
Celestia smiled lovingly and touched the tip of her glowing horn to Sunset’s forehead. “I am very proud of you, my student.” Sunset felt a sleepy warmth creeping through her. “When you awaken, your new lessons will begin. But I warn you, to learn about the Magic of Friendship, you need to return to an earlier level.”
“Are you sending me back to Magic Kindergarten?” Sunset asked drowsily, her head drooping towards the ground.
Celestia chuckled, and there was a wicked edge to the laughter that sent a thrill through Sunset’s body, bringing to mind other lessons Sunset had learned from the alicorn. “Not exactly. Sleep now. And though your path may be difficult, I hope you enjoy it. We cannot speak often, but I will be watching. And I certainly intend to enjoy myself.”
Before Sunset could ask what Celestia meant, she was out like a light once again.
------------------------------
“What in tarnation?” The voice was familiar, but Sunset couldn’t place it…couldn’t think of much of anything. Her mind was in a fog, and she couldn’t even summon the concentration necessary to open her eyes.
“Whoa, awesome! It’s just like Principal…I mean Princess…whatever, it’s just like Celestia said it would be in the dream!” A new voice…Sunset tried to stir but found that her body wouldn’t obey her. That should have been frightening, but her mind was just so muddled.
A third voice spoke primly, in a hushed tone. “Both of you are simply being far too loud! You’ll wake the poor dear, and we can’t have that until we get her…” Sleep was coming yet again, and the voices faded into a background mumble. Sunset felt herself being picked up and cradled by soft arms against what felt like a fairly ample chest. She managed just enough curiosity to wonder how she could be lifted so effortlessly, and then she was gone again.
------------------------------
With a bit of a start, Sunset Shimmer finally snapped back to full consciousness. The last thing she remembered clearly was getting back to her apartment. Everything after that was a strange, fuzzy blur. “Just a dream?” she muttered vaguely. Then she frowned slightly, realizing she wasn’t lying on her couch…it felt like a bed. She sat up, or tried to. Her eyes opened wide with shock as she realized she was tied down, spread-eagle.
Sunset craned her head up to look over herself and realized she was completely naked, but at this point she’d almost expected that. The biggest shock of all however were her breasts…they were gone! Well not gone precisely, but reduced to a pair of tiny, puffy mounds on her amber-colored chest. Her hips were far slimmer, and between her legs her sex was flat, smooth and immature. Even her arms and legs seemed shorter and more slender. Her formerly teenaged body had been reduced to that of a barely pubescent girl!
She twisted her head around to look at her restraints, noting as she did that her hair, which had previously poured all the way down to her thighs in a red and gold cascade, now felt like it reached just halfway down her back. Her wrists and ankles were secured by loops of soft fabric with something stronger underneath, leather or something similar. The cuffs were attached to lengths of rope that went off the corners of the bed and out of sight. After pulling with all her might for several long moment, it became obvious that she wasn’t going anywhere for the time being.
The bed itself was rather plain, a soft mattress with white sheets, with a simple but sturdy headboard. The light in the room was pretty dim, but from what she could see the walls looked like wooden planks painted in soft colors. Taking a deep breath, Sunset gathered her courage and called out, “Hello?” Her voice was quivery with fear, and somewhat higher pitched than she was used to. “Is…is anyone there?” she continued, trying to make her voice a bit stronger. “Where am I? What…what’s h-happened to m-me?” Thinking about her transformation brought all the fear rushing back and made her stutter. “P-please, someone…someone h-help!”
“Hey, you were right, she is up,” a familiar female voice said from somewhere behind her.
A second voice responded in a cowboy drawl, “Ah told you Ah heard her callin’.” Suddenly two faces were looking down at her over the headboard and smiling reassuringly.
“Applejack! Rainbow Dash!” Sunset reflexively tried to cover her nakedness but the restraints, of course, prevented that. “What’s going on? How did I get here? What happened to me?!” Sunset wasn’t sure if she should be more frightened or less by the presence of the other girls.
“Hush now, sugar.” The two teens moved around to sit on opposite sides of the bed. Sunset’s eyes widened a bit when she saw they were naked as well. Well, Applejack was still wearing her hat, but every inch of her light orange skin was bare, except for the long blonde mane that hid her back. Rainbow’s multi-colored hair was tossed over once shoulder, obscuring one of her perky little blue breasts. Both girls were very athletic, with tight, lean muscles. Rainbow’s body was a little slimmer, but Applejack had more rounded hips and a much more buxom chest.
“Everything’s gonna be fine,” Rainbow said while reaching out to pat Sunset on the leg. She pulled back when the smaller girl tried to move away, though.
“Try ta remember,” Applejack urged softly. “Didja have a dream? A dream about where ya came from?”
Sunset gasped, “I…I did!” The memory of the dream she’d had about Princess Celestia came flooding back. “But how did you…?”
Rainbow chuckled. “We had a dream too, us and Rarity. Principal Celestia looks pretty good as a pony, huh?”
“Focus,” Applejack ordered wryly, giving Rainbow a quick poke in the shoulder. “Anyway, yer Celestia told us that you were gonna be goin’ through some 'changes.' And we were s’posed to help ya out.”
“Changes…?” Sunset laughed, but there was a bit of a hysterical edge to it. “Yeah, this is kind of a change! Look at me!” Sunset’s thoughts and feelings were even more of a jumbled mess than she would have imagined. She was beginning to think that her emotional state, and even her comprehension abilities had been regressed along with her body. And that was even scarier.
Applejack reached out to stroke Sunset’s hair, and Sunset jerked away. Unlike Rainbow, however, Applejack didn’t back off, and as Sunset felt the gentle caress on her head, she leaned into it without thinking. “Ah know it’s scary little darlin’, but she told us this was somethin’ you needed to do. Was she right?”
Sunset remembered the choice she’d made, and suddenly a lot of what Celestia had told her made more sense. Tears pricked at her eyelids. It wasn’t just how frightening the situation was, it was also Applejack’s hand on her—she couldn’t remember the last time she’d been touched so lovingly. Finally, she nodded. “I guess I did sign up for this,” she whispered.
Rainbow’s hand slipped over hers in it’s binding and gave it a little squeeze. “Alright then,” she said confidently. “Tomorrow, we’re supposed to introduce you to our little sisters.” She smirked. “Well, Scootaloo isn’t exactly my little sis, but I guess you could say I sorta adopted the little squirt.”
Applejack interjected with a tone of wicked amusement, “Little squirt, huh? Ah think Apple Bloom told me a story or two about how Scoots got that nickname.”
Sunset cleared her throat and tried to keep her voice calm. “Okay, so then why am I tied down? And how come we’re all naked?!”
Rainbow and AJ looked at each other, then smiled down at the now-younger girl again. And though the smiles were still kind, there was a certain sort of hungry quality to them that made the butterflies already in her stomach start fluttering even harder.
“The thing you gotta understand about the little Crusaders,” Applejack explained, using the group’s nickname, “the three of them are real, real close.”
“And even when we weren’t friends, well, we were pretty ‘close’ to them too,” Rainbow continued with a snicker. “Even though we usually only play with our own little sisters.”
“This is actually their clubhouse, out in my family’s orchard,” Applejack added, looking around the small room. “Dashie and I were just, um, gettin’ reacquainted outside on the grass while we were waitin’ for you ta wake up an’ Rarity ta get back.”
“S-so how c-come I’m t-tied down?” Sunset asked, stuttering again. Though this time it wasn’t only fear making her do it. At least, not exactly.
“That’s just a lil’ precaution, so we could be sure yah didn’t get spooked and run off,” Applejack said with a little wink.
“Yeah, one thing the Princess told us to do specifically was make sure you’d ‘fit in’ with the girls.” Rainbow’s voice took on a husky edge as she played with the cuff on Sunset’s closest ankle, then let her fingers trail up the creamy amber calf up to the knee. The light touch left little sparks in its wake as it slid over Sunset’s skin, and she shivered. “Oooo…I think she’ll fit in just fine!”
“Rainbow,” Applejack’s voice held a distinct note of warning. “Y’know Rarity said we weren’t s’posed to get started till she got back…”
“The only thing I just heard was ‘Rarity isn’t here,’” Rainbow said with a chuckle and wink at Sunset. The newly little girl managed a shaky smile back. “So we don’t really have to listen to Miss Bossypants. Besides…” Rainbow looked right at Sunset’s small pussy and licked her lips hungrily. Sunset reflexively pulled her thighs together, the restraints making her knock-kneed as she vainly tried to cover herself. “Would you look at that? So plump and soft and pretty…I need to get a taste.”
“Ah think a little foreplay is in order,” Applejack said firmly. “Can’t be scarin’ the poor thing by rushin’ ta the finish line all at once.” The blonde girl laid out on the bed, cuddling to Sunset’s side. Sunset could feel AJ’s breasts against her shoulder, and it made her entire body tingle. Applejack used one finger under Sunset’s chin to turn the smaller girl’s head towards hers and smiled seductively. “Nothin’ wrong with easin’ inta things with a kiss, huh?”
Sunset bit her lip. “I’m so confused,” she whimpered softly.
Applejack smiled and ran her fingers over Sunset’s forehead. “Aw darlin’, Ah can’t even imagine how strange this must feel,” she murmured. “But Ah promise, we ain’t gonna do anythin’ to hurt you. We promised Twilight, and we’re yer friends now, thick and thin.”
“That’s right,” Rainbow added, leaning over to smile down at Sunset over the top of Applejack’s head. “You can count on us. Magical flying unicorn princess or no magical flying unicorn princess, if you really want us to, we’ll untie you and take you back home right now.”
“But in that dream we had, Celestia made it pretty darn clear that if ya want what she offered in yer dream, this has gotta happen.” Applejack leaned in and gave the tip of Sunset’s nose a little lick. “And Ah promise, it’ll be fun!”
Sunset thought about her dream, thought about what Princess Celestia had offered her…and wryly wondered just how ‘necessary’ this really was. Still…
Sunset leaned up and caught Applejack’s lips with hers. Applejack smiled into the kiss and started to return it, then gave a muffled little cry of surprise as Sunset sucked the blonde girl’s tongue into her mouth. Sunset twined her tongue expertly around AJ’s, devouring the other girl’s mouth in long, deep kiss.
With a wet little pop, Sunset ended the kiss and Applejack slumped back onto the bed, wearing flushed cheeks and a quite nonplussed expression. “Sweet sticky applesauce!” she said when she finally caught her breath. “I guess I sorta forgot ya only look like a little kid!”
Sunset gave a somewhat self-conscious little giggle, a pink flush on her own yellow cheeks. “I wanna try!” Rainbow Dash exclaimed and Sunset’s eyes widened and then closed as Rainbow dove in and kissed her, pressing her tongue between the young girl’s lips. Rainbow was a more combative kisser than Applejack, and Sunset found their tongues twisting and pressing against each other as they both tried to dominate the kiss.
After several long, sweet and spicy moments Rainbow pulled back, her lips and chin glistening as she grinned. “That was awesome!”
“Ah know, right?” Applejack chuckled as she rested a hand on Sunset’s naked stomach.
Rainbow tried to look nonchalant as she sat up and slid her hand high up on Sunset’s slender thigh. “So, can we do this now?”
Applejack rolled her eyes and shook her head with a sigh and a rueful smile on her face. “Rainbow, anyone ever mention ya got what ya might call a fixation?”
The light blue teen just stuck her tongue out and said, “Hey I didn’t hear you complaining when I was fixating on you outside!”
Applejack put a finger to her mouth to shush the rainbow-haired girl for a moment and then smiled encouragingly down at Sunset. “Alrighty, Sunset darlin’…if ya feel like yer ready, Rainbow wants to try somethin’ that’s…”
Rainbow interrupted with a very impatient click of her tongue. “She’s not a little kid! Did you forget that kiss already?” With a lithe little twist of her body, Rainbow placed herself on her knees between Sunset’s skinny, spread legs. She ran her fingers over the young girl’s hips, causing Sunset to let out her breath in an excited hiss as the other girl dug her nails in slightly. “I want to go down on you,” Rainbow told her as she smiled down boldly. “And if you say yes it is gonna be the ride of your life! Flash Sentry’s got nothing on my skill.”
Sunset squirmed in place slightly. “Flash and I never…” she closed her mouth tightly, but it was too late.
Both Applejack and Rainbow Dash looked down at her in surprise. “You didn’t?” Rainbow asked.
“Ah heard th’ two of ya almost got expelled ‘cause Principal Celestia caught ya goin’ at it in her office!” Applejack exclaimed.
“And I heard you got banned from the library for life after what Miss Cheerilee caught you doing in the old map room!” Rainbow chimed in.
Sunset’s honey-colored cheeks were a deep pink by now, and the blush spread all the way down her neck to her delectably flat chest. “I started those rumors, okay?” she burst out angrily. “Because Flash wouldn’t do it with me! He always said it ‘wasn’t the right time’ or ‘it needed to be special’ or some other load of horseapples! In fact, he broke up with me because he thought I was being soooo pushy about it! So no, I’ve never done anything but kiss with anyone! Happy now?” Sunset turned her flaming face away and forced herself to stop trying to fold her arms in a huff.
Above her, Rainbow and AJ looked down, then at each other for a moment, and then Rainbow’s face broke out in an eager grin. “Well, that’s all I needed to hear! Buckle up Sunny, your mind is about to be blown!” Without even giving sunset a chance to express her displeasure at being called ‘Sunny,’ Rainbow dropped down onto her chest, opened her mouth wide and completely engulfed the small girl’s pussy.
Sunset tried to suck in a breath and found that she couldn’t. Rainbow’s mouth on her sex, that soft, hot, wet pressure… “Oh CelestiiiiiEEEEEEE!” Sunset squealed loudly as she felt something even hotter and wetter sliding up and down and in and out and all over. The newly-little girl lost all control of her body, her arms and legs straining against her bonds in an attempt to latch all of them around Rainbow.
Finally she managed to press her head back against the pillow and force out, “Nuh! Not so hard!” Rainbow immediately backed off. Sunset struggled to raise her head and saw Rainbow’s red eyes sparkling with amusement as she peeked up at her over the bright pink mound of her vulva.
“Just giving you a taste of the good stuff,” Rainbow said teasingly. Her hands slid up the sides of Sunset’s thighs, making her twitch ticklishly. “Well, I was actually giving me a taste of the good stuff.” Rainbow’s tongue gave the glistening little peach another quick swipe. “MmmmmmMMM!” Rainbow licked her lips hungrily. “Now that’s a candy vag!”
Sunset opened her mouth to say something, but she didn’t know what. She ended up just staring down at Rainbow with her lips slightly parted and her cheeks bright red. Rainbow chuckled, rose up on her elbows and gave Sunset a kiss just underneath her belly button. “Alright,” the blue girl murmured, “that was fun. Let’s get down to business…” With a far gentler, slower touch than before, Rainbow began tonguing Sunset’s juicy little quim.
“Ohhhhhhh, that’s better!” Sunset let out a long sigh that ended in a soft moan as Rainbow’s mouth caressed a particularly exciting spot. Sunset’s whole body was still tingling from the first assault, but now it almost felt like she was melting against the bed. She parted her legs wider and rolled her hips up against Rainbow’s mouth. “Ohhh, mmm…way, waaaaay better!”
She started as she felt a gentle hand on her shoulder and looked up to see Applejack smiling down at her, a flush on her golden cheeks. Sunset had almost forgotten she was there. “Feelin’ good, sugar?” AJ asked her as her hand slid down the young girl’s chest to caress her nascent breasts and puffy little nipple.
“Mmm, yes…” Sunset groaned languidly, arching her back into Applejack’s soft, strong hand.
“Y’know, I thought ya were smokin’ hot when ya were grown up,” Applejack said with a rueful chuckle as she continued stroking her fingers over Sunset’s sensitive chest. “Even if ya were a bitch.”
“Uh-huh…” Sunset barely heard her. Rainbow’s tongue felt so good, and her stiff little nipples were so sensitive! Was it because they were growing? Sunset wasn’t sure, but every time AJ ran her fingertip over them it sent out a little electric spark that went right down to her creamy pussy.
“And you’re an awfully cute little filly,” Applejack breathed. “I just want to saddle you up and take you for a ride.”
“Uh-huh…wait, what?” Sunset blinked and looked up at Applejack, her eyes wide. Rainbow paused and looked up as well, confused by the sudden change in mood.
Suddenly, AJ looked worried. “Uh-oh, Ah didn’t just say somethin’ super offensive for pony folk, did Ah?”
She…had. Saddles…riding…why didn’t she just say she wanted to pull on Sunset’s reins and put the spurs to her?! But then, even back in Equestria, Sunset’s fantasies were a little kinky. And after becoming Princess Celestia’s student they just got worse and worse.
She smiled up at Applejack and licked her lips. “You…can ride me anytime,” she whispered.
Applejack gave her a sultry smile and leaned in for another quick kiss. “That’s mah sexy little pony,” she whispered back. Moving slowly and carefully, the strong blonde girl mounted Sunset’s face, facing the headboard while slipping her legs underneath the flame-haired girl’s outstretched arms. Dash paused to let the blonde move into place. Suddenly Sunset found herself just inches away from AJ’s pussy, the apricot-colored skin flushed pink and shining wet with excitement. Her eyes went wide, and she thrust her hips up pleadingly towards Rainbow Dash, but the sporty girl was just watching for the moment.
“Alright little filly,” Applejack was saying in a soft voice that was trembling with eagerness. “Just gonna ease into the saddle now…oh, wait…” AJ leaned forward and quickly untied the knots holding Sunset’s left arm. Sunset blinked in surprise as she stretched her free limb.
“Why…?”
Applejack grinned wickedly. “Ah’m probably gonna ride ya pretty hard once I got ya broken in, sugar. That’s so ya can give me a little tap if Ah need to let ya up fer air.”
A shudder passed all through Sunset’s body, from her chest down to her legs. She already felt a little short of breath, but she nodded and even managed to smile a little as she said, “Thanks.” Sunset’s change really was more than skin deep; she could barely think from all the conflicting thoughts and emotions that held her paralyzed. She hadn’t felt this jumbled up since she was a filly the first time around. Actually, even back then she didn’t remember feeling quite so…
Her moment of introspection was cut short as Applejack lowered her pussy onto Sunset’s face. Her hand immediately shot up onto AJ’s thigh, but she didn’t want the older girl to move yet. Instead, she just grabbed onto the leg for support as she opened her mouth and began probing at the farm girl’s soft, dewy folds with her tongue. “Mmmm, that’s it girl, nice and easy, nice and easy,” Applejack softly urged her on. “Find yer pace, but don’t be afraid to push!” As she spoke, she began pushing down a little harder, letting her hips press down on Sunset’s face in time with the small girl’s hesitant licks. Encouraged, Sunset started lapping more enthusiastically, and was rewarded by AJ moaning deep in her throat and bearing down against her face. “Ohhhh, fuck yes, just like that!”
Rainbow Dash chose that moment to slide her tongue into Sunset’s labia again, quickly finding her tiny little clitoris and giving it a soft, long, stroke. Sunset’s eyes shut tight at the overpoweringly wonderful sensation, and she thrust her tongue deep into Applejack’s yielding canal while digging her nails into the girl’s thigh. AJ let out a long, guttural cry and thrust her hips down hard, letting her full weight sit on the little girl’s face for the first time. Her thighs squeezed the little redhead tight, and Sunset could hear the blood pounding in her ears.
But she was past caring. Her legs were fighting her bonds as hard as they could, frantically trying to wrap around Rainbow’s shoulders. Looking up, she could see Applejack’s head hanging down, her eyes closed and her mouth open, a tiny little thread of drool dripping to her breast as her whole back rolled back and forth at a steady pace, just like a girl on a pony. She was just as much out of her mind with pleasure as Sunset, and the little girl loved that she was the one making AJ feel this way.
She pushed her face up into Applejack’s pussy and fucked with her tongue as hard as she could. It seemed like all three of them were moving in perfect rhythm, with Applejack riding her face, Sunset licking in and out and pushing her hips up into Rainbow’s mouth, who licked and sucked greedily at the immature sex.
Applejack put a hand over Sunset’s free one, and used the other to get a handful of Sunset’s fire-colored hair, pulling up lightly as if she were pulling on reins. Sunset groaned into AJ’s cunt and kept her tongue moving. Her nose and mouth were full of the smell and taste of the strong girl’s juices, and it was setting her whole body on fire. “Mmmmmffffuck!” Applejack moaned. “Oh, you sweet, sexy, little pony! Just keep flutterin’ that tongue! Flutter it!”
Rainbow was bringing Sunset to the edge, and fast. She’d found a perfect pattern to run from Sunset’s tight little hole up to her tiny, twitching button, and it was making a tingly, breathless pleasure build up inside Sunset…
Breathless…all of a sudden Sunset realized her lungs were burning for air, and little flashing lights seemed to be going off inside her head. She frantically patted Applejack’s thigh, and the other girl eased off a bit, allowing Sunset to suck in a welcome breath.
But only one. As Rainbow continued relentlessly forcing her young body towards climax, Applejack was getting close as well. The hand in Sunset’s hair let go, and the tawny girl began frigging her own clit in a tight little circle. Her hips started bucking down at a short, hard pace, each movement allowing Sunset a quick gasp. Sunset tried to keep licking, but it became very clear very fast that now AJ was just using her petite, delicate face to rub her creaming pussy against.
“Ride me,” Sunset grunted. “Lick me! Fuck!” She went rigid and her whole body tried to twist over to one side. “Fuck mmmmmmeeeeEEEEEEEEmmmpppphh!” Her final, ear-piercing shriek was cut off by Applejack sitting down hard against her face as the cowgirl began to come as well. Sunset just felt wave after wave of pure white pleasure rush through her body like a lightning bolt, and she tried to drink up as much of Applejack’s salty-sweet honey as she could.
She must have grayed out for a moment, because when she came back to herself fully, Applejack was slumped, panting against the side of the bed. And Rainbow was right beside her, licking the glistening cream from her small face. “You…do…have…a fixation…” Sunset murmured as she smiled, and Rainbow smiled back.
“Hey, I know what I like!”
“WHAT ON EARTH IS GOING ON HERE?!” The strident, outraged cry made all three girls jump. Rarity was standing in the doorway, her eyes blazing. She was wearing a dark blue long-sleeved short dress that left her shoulders bare, along with black leggings. In one hand she held a black shopping bag, and a loose bundle of clothing was in the crook of her other arm. She also looked very, very angry.
“I knew when I found all these,” she gestured with the loose bundle, “outside that you two had gotten up to no good! And look at you! And look at her! And…and…!” She sniffed the air. “It simply reeks of sex in here! I wasn’t gone for half an hour and you two couldn’t wait that long? Do the words ‘self-control’ not mean anything to either of you! You’ve probably frightened the poor girl half to death!”
Rarity paused for breath and walked over to the bed. Rainbow scrambled off it and stood, managing to look a little contrite with her arms folded under her breasts. Sunset smiled up at Rarity, hoping to defuse the situation somewhat. “Actually, I liked it all,” she said in as sunny a tone as she could make it. “I wanted it just as much as they did.”
The fashionista had been opening her mouth to begin the tirade anew, but when Sunset spoke she puffed her cheeks out and let out her breath in a very dissatisfied sigh. “I wanted it just as badly,” the purple-haired girl muttered. She reached out a hand and brushed back the hair that had gotten stuck to Sunset’s forehead. “Such a mess,” she sighed again, but ended with a faint smile.
“So uh, we’re awful sorry, Rarity. Guess we just couldn’t help ourselves.” Applejack offered timidly.
“Yeah, but no harm no foul, right? Give us a second and we’ll be all set for round two!” Rainbow chimed in eagerly.
The tiny smile on Rarity’s snow-white face turned sinister. “Round two? Oh my, no. I think you two have had quite enough fun for one night. In fact, I think you should both be heading to bed. Now.” She straightened up and crossed her arms, looking from one girl to the next, daring either one to contradict her.
“Well, Ah guess we did have our fun,” Applejack muttered as she pushed herself to her feet.
”Hey! But I…” Rainbow began to protest, but Rarity cut her off with a look. “I mean…yeah. Fair’s fair. I guess.”
“So if we can just have our clothes…” Applejack reached out a hand, but Rarity twisted away, an absolutely diabolical smile on her face.
“Clothes? What clothes?” Rarity quickly popped the bundle of garments into the bag she was holding. “You’d better hurry back to the farmhouse, dear. Hopefully Mac or Granny Smith aren’t taking a stroll through the orchard. The moon is quite bright this evening.”
“Naked run in the moonlight?” Rainbow suddenly looked a lot more chipper. “Now that sounds like fun! C’mon AJ, I’ll race you back!” Applejack looked somewhat less enthused, but let Rainbow pull her to the door. Then just as they were leaving, Rainbow stopped. “Hey wait a second! I didn’t get off yet!”
Applejack put her hand on the jock’s shoulders and smiled. “If we can get to the farmhouse and my bedroom without getting’ caught, Ah’ll see what Ah can do about it.” Applejack pushed Rainbow through the door and down the ramp outside. The sounds of bare feet running over grass started, then faded into the distance. Rarity and Sunset were alone.
Rarity had her hands on her hips as she looked at the empty doorway. “Ruffians,” she muttered, shaking her head ruefully. She turned back to Sunset with a soft smile on her face. “Well, Sunset…I have to admit, I was hoping we’d get some time alone together.” She walked over to the bed and released the cuffs still binding Sunset down one by one. The fiery girl sat on the side of the bed and gave a huge stretch. Rarity sat beside her, holding a hairbrush. “Come here, darling, and we’ll talk,” she said, patting her lap.
Sunset blushed deeply, but climbed into Rarity’s lap without a word. She was actually rather afraid to say anything to the lovely, glamorous girl. Out of all of Twilight’s friends, she’d hurt Rarity the most.
But now Rarity was running a hand over her damp hair and tsking softly. “Such a mess…those girls…” She began brushing out Sunset’s gold and crimson locks, letting her other hand rest gently on the small girl’s naked thighs. After this had gone on in silence for some time, Sunset began to forget her nervousness. She closed her eyes and leaned against Rarity’s shoulder. One of her arms draped over Rarity’s.
“So small, so cute,” Rarity said in a very soft voice, just a hair above a whisper. “It’s hard to remember you’re the same girl that ruined me during the Spring Fling.” Sunset tensed up and froze, but Rarity just continued brushing and talking as if she didn’t notice. “I was so humiliated, you know. Couldn’t show my face until after summer vacation. Oh, all the disguises were fun, at first, but,” she paused for a moment with a tiny sigh before continuing, “but it does still hurt.”
Sunset burst into tears, surprising both of them. All the twisted up feelings that had her wound tighter than a harpstring suddenly came bursting out to the surface. “I’m suh-huh-ooory!” she sobbed, nearly in hysterics. She wrapped her arms around her flat, naked chest and shook. She tried to speak again, but she couldn’t force any words past the tears.
Then Rarity enfolded her in a gentle embrace and held the little girl to her chest, running a hand over her hair. “Hush, hush, darling,” she said, along with a lot of other soft words and soothing noises as Sunset cried herself out. As the harder sobs faded into quieter weeping, Rarity murmured, “It’s going to be alright, it really is.”
Sunset replied in a ragged voice, “How can it be? After what I did to everyone, to you, especially! I’m not…I can’t…” She sniffed and pushed her face into Rarity’s now quite damp shoulder. “I’m sorry,” she repeated in a plaintive, muffled voice.
She felt Rarity’s hand slip under her chin and tilt her face up to meet the older girl’s gaze. Rarity was smiling down at her tenderly, her deep blue eyes shining. “I forgive you, Sunset,” she said simply.
The small girl felt her lip trembling again. “How can you?”
“How can I not?” Rarity replied gracefully. From out of a sleeve the purple-haired teen produced a handkerchief and dabbed at Sunset’s tear-streaked face. “I don’t think you’re the same person who did those terrible things. I don’t think you ever really were that person, you just lied to yourself until you believed you were. And the person on my lap is a sad, confused, sweet little girl that needs something that I can give her.” Rarity leaned down and gave Sunset a gentle kiss on the cheek. “You have my forgiveness, Sunset Shimmer.”
Tears sprang up in Sunset’s eyes again, but this time they were tears of gratitude. Impulsively, she leaned up to give Rarity a sweet little kiss on the lips. But despite her innocent intent, their lips lingered together. And then Sunset parted hers, and felt Rarity’s tongue slide into her mouth. Sunset turned in her seat so that she was straddling Rarity’s waist, and then there was nothing little about the kiss at all. But it was still very sweet.
When the kiss broke, Rarity licked Sunset’s chin clean. She whispered teasingly, “You still taste like Applejack,” then chuckled as Sunset blushed. “Oh Darling, I hadn’t expected you to be such a wonderful kisser!” she continued, running her hands down Sunset’s naked sides and making the small girl squirm. Sunset buried her face between Rarity’s breasts, and felt the lovely teen suck in a deep breath, then let it out with a sigh.
“My little Sunset likes Momma’s breasts, does she?” Rarity’s voice was loving and seductive, and when Sunset looked up there was a look on Rarity’s snow-white face that made the little girl shiver.
“Y-yes…Momma,” Sunset said the word in a tiny, nervous whisper. Rarity made a sound that was almost an actual purr and her hands tightened on Sunset’s hips. “I love them.” Her small hands came up to rest on Rarity’s impressive bust. They felt so warm, even through the dress, and they were even bigger than Applejack’s.
“Well then,” Rarity reached behind herself for a moment, and then reached down the front of her dress to pull out her bra and toss it aside. “I think my precious little Sunset should have a better look!” Moving carefully, she pulled one arm, then the other out of the dress’ sleeves, then pushed the entire garment down to her stomach, exposing her chest to the air and, much more importantly, to Sunset.
The citrine girl held her breath as she rested her hands on Rarity’s voluptuous orbs. They were as white as china, of course, perfectly formed and pert and perky, despite their size. Her nipples were a lovely violet, almost the same color as her hair, and they grew quite stiff the moment Sunset’s hand touched the pale skin.
After enjoying Sunset’s gentle caresses for a little while, Rarity put her left hand behind Sunset’s head and cupped her own breast with her right, using both to guide Sunset’s lips to her nipple. “Now, my precious gem, I think it’s time to put that talented mouth to work. Be a good girl and suckle Momma’s titties…”
Sunset complied without a moment of hesitation. She closed her lips around the straining purple nub and sucked, sliding her tongue over the tip. Rarity let out a soft moan of pure pleasure and draped her arms loosely over Sunset’s shoulders. Sunset opened her mouth wide and closed it again, lightly scraping her teeth over the perfect skin until she could nibble lightly on the nipple once more. Rarity gasped and arched her back into Sunset’s greedy mouth in response. “That’s Momma’s naughty little girl,” she cooed.
Once Sunset had covered the entire globe with wet, hungry kisses, Rarity guided the fire-headed girl to the other breast and let her go to work all over again. Sunset felt like she was practically melting into the other girl. The aroma of Rarity’s designer perfume was everywhere, and under that the scent of female sex still pervaded the room. It was making Sunset’s newly-stirred up hormones go into overdrive. Her head was spinning…she almost felt drunk. “Warm…soft…” she moaned in between licks.
Rarity cupped both Sunset’s cheeks in her hands and tilted her small face up. There was an audible ‘pop’ as Sunset’s lips left Rarity’s flesh. Rarity was smiling into her eyes with a loving expression. “Does Momma’s sweet little girl want to play?” she asked with a wink.
“Mmm…huh? What?” Sunset licked her lips and tried to focus on what Rarity had just said. “Play?”
The fashionista reached down off the bed and picked up the shopping bag she had entered the treehouse with. “I’ve got a special toy that I brought just for you.”
Sunset felt her pussy tingle at the promise in those words, and her legs tightened around Rarity’s waist. She buried her face in the ‘older’ girl’s ample cleavage and smiled up at her impishly as she chirped, “I wanna play with you, Momma!”
Rarity gave the small, naked girl in her lap a tight, eager hug. “That’s just what I wanted to hear, darling!” She turned and pushed Sunset back against the bed again, pausing to give her another quick, deep kiss that ended with Sunset sucking on Rarity’s tongue as the violet-haired girl moved away.
As Sunset watched, Rarity let the dress fall to the floor. Of course, she promptly picked it up, folded it carefully and put it in the bag. Then Rarity turned with a devious smile and eased her black panties off, bending over double to give Sunset a breathtaking view of her perfect, lily-white ass, and just a hint of the dewy, pearly lips beneath. Sunset groaned, one hand playing with her budding breast while the other lightly toyed with her own slit.
Once her panties were gone and her trendy little flats had been kicked off, Rarity stood there in just the black leggings. She reached into the bag. “Well now…what have we…here!” Sunset’s eyes widened as Rarity pulled out a strap on dildo on a black vinyl harness into view. The dildo itself was a transparent light purple color, ribbed and, Sunset noted with some trepidation, only a little smaller than the toys she had at home. Toys she’d bought when she had a teenager’s body.
But there was something on the dildo’s other end that Sunset didn’t recognize, a sort of upswept part that ended in a rounded bulb. Sunset didn’t quite get what that was for…until Rarity pulled the harness up and Sunset realized where it was pointing. Rarity paused and gave Sunset a little smile, running her tongue over her upper teeth. “Would little Sunset like to help Momma put her toy on?”
Sunset nodded and smiled, slipping off the bed and kneeling down beside Rarity. As she helped the teen pull the tight, shiny harness up her snowy thighs, she admired Rarity’s lovely pussy, the milky skin just slightly pink with arousal, her sweet honey making the smooth flesh glisten below a small, perfectly sculpted little landing strip of violet hair.
Rarity noticed her look and chuckled. “Give Momma a kiss before we start, dear,” she purred, using two fingers to frame her clit where it peeked out from between the folds of her labia. “Right here.”
Sunset shivered and arched her back. “Yes, Momma,” she replied meekly, and was rewarded by a suppressed squeal of delight from the older girl. She leaned in and gave the little button a soft kiss, ending by teasing it with her tongue.
Rarity moaned behind closed lips. “Mmmm, such a sweet girl.” She reached down and placed her hand on Sunset’s head. “Now help Momma get this toy on, and we’ll be ready for your fucking.” The last word came out in an eager hiss that made Sunset bite her lip. As Rarity pulled the harness up Sunset guided the bulb into the teenager’s dripping pussy, making Rarity moan and twist in place as the toy slid home.
Once it was in place, Rarity cupped Sunset’s cheek in her hand and directed, “Now, Sunset sweetie, make it nice and wet.”
“Yes Momma,” Sunset said, licking the smooth, molded surface all over. As she coated the dildo in saliva, she thought she could detect a faint flavor, and she looked up askance at Rarity.
The white-skinned girl grinned. “Oh yes, darling. This toy has some experience. I’ve used it on Sweetie Belle at least a dozen times. Scootaloo twice, and Apple Bloom once. Do you like my baby sister’s pussy juice? Mmmm…you’ll be able to taste it from the source soon enough!”
The thought that Rarity had used this toy to fuck her own little sister sent a wicked, forbidden thrill through Sunset’s whole body. She sucked and licked the rounded tip of the dildo even more enthusiastically. When the entire toy glistened wetly, Rarity touched the top of Sunset’s head. “Enough, darling. Up on the bed now, that’s a good girl.”
Sunset nodded and clambered back onto the bed. She lay on her back, propping herself up by her elbows to watch as Rarity climbed gracefully onto the mattress as well. Smiling seductively, the pale teen knelt just below Sunset’s feet and touched the young girl’s ankles with her index fingers. Sunset spread her legs open in response to the unspoken command and began to tremble slightly. As Rarity crawled between her outstretched legs, the strap-on bobbing with her movements, Sunset began to feel incredibly small and helpless.
That feeling only increased when Rarity grabbed hold of her ankles and lifted them into the air, completely exposing her immature cunt to Rarity’s appraising eyes. “Mmm, still so wet,” she cooed. “I should thank the other girls for priming the pump for me.” She laughed softly as Sunset blushed, the red flush spreading over her orange cheeks and chest.
Sunset grabbed the sheets tightly in both fists as Rarity stretched her legs apart further. “Be gentle, Momma!” she gasped as she felt the tip of the toy press her opening.
Rarity paused and smiled. “Momma’s always gentle with her precious little gems,” Rarity assured her. A wicked smile played across her lips as she pushed with her hips and began to enter the small girl. Sunset’s eyes widened and her toes began to curl tightly. “Of course, the first time does take a bit of…force!” The last word was spoken with a soft grunt as Rarity thrust forward. There was a tearing sensation and a flash of bright pain that caused Sunset to cry out in a tiny squeak.
With a shock, the little girl realized her virginity had just been taken. At least this time I didn’t have to do it to myself, came the random thought. The pain quickly faded, and Sunset felt pleasure welling up in its place as the smooth, ribbed surface kept rubbing her canal deeper and deeper with every thrust. She opened her eyes, noticing only then that she’d clenched them shut when her cherry had popped.
Rarity was smiling down at her, her white cheeks flushed pink with the pleasure she was receiving from her end of the toy. “Such a brave girl,” she praised. “Momma’s brave little girls get yummy treats!” She leaned forward, letting Sunset’s heels rest on her shoulders as she thrust in deep and pulled out slowly. “Is it yummy, Sunset?”
Sunset’s eyes rolled back and she squirmed against the mattress, pushing her hips up to meet Rarity’s thrusts. “Sooo yummy!” she moaned. Rarity moaned as well, and used the mingled sound as a signal to begin fucking the young girl harder. Nearly the full length of the dildo was sliding in and out of her, and that seemed to be as far as it would go easily. But it was enough!
Sunset began squeaking and squealing louder and louder as Rarity began to move faster and faster. Rarity’s head tilted up, tossing her violet hair back as she closed her eyes and let herself lose control. Sunset was amazed at how flexible her young body was. Rarity kept leaning further and further forward, and now Sunset’s knees and chest were coming very close to touching.
Rarity placed her hands on the mattress above Sunset’s shoulders and opened her eyes. Sunset could feel the heat in those deep blue jewels as they locked gazes, and it held her paralyzed. “Come with me, Sunset,” Rarity panted, pumping the dildo hard enough that the sound of their skin slapping together filled the air. “Come with Momma!”
Sunset opened her mouth, but only a tiny little mewling sound escaped. Rarity fell forward, and Sunset’s legs clamped tight around her waist. Their lips met, and their tongues twisted in a fevered kiss. For the second time that evening, Sunset’s orgasmic shriek was muffled by the body of another girl, but this time she could feel the low, guttural moan as Rarity cried out with her own climax.
Rarity clung tightly to Sunset’s shoulders and rolled them over so that the smaller girl was on top. The toy slid from Sunset’s slick pussy and rubbed against her thigh. Rarity continued hugging her tightly and nuzzling her neck and shoulder. “That was glorious darling,” the elegant girl whispered into her ear.
Sunset giggled tiredly. “Yes, it was!” Her hand came up and caressed Rarity’s creamy breast. Rarity let out a little satisfied trill at the sensation. Sunset began to speak again, but a massive yawn cut her short. “’M sorry,” she mumbled, suddenly in the grip of deep exhaustion. “Just a little…tired.”
Rarity made a soft, understanding sound. “Of course, Sunset dear, you’ve had a very busy night, and you are just a little girl.”
“I think…” Sunset yawned again and wriggled down so that her cheek was resting against Rarity’s naturally warm, soft pillows. “I think I’m going to like being a little filly again,” she murmured. She glanced up at the other girl, a bit of tired, distant concern in her eyes. “Will they like me?” she asked softly. “Your sister, and the others?”
“Goodness yes,” Rarity said in a motherly tone, stroking Sunset’s sweaty hair with the back of her fingers.
“That’s…good.” Sunset’s eyes drooped closed, and just moments later her small chest began to rise and fall with the regularity of deep sleep.
Rarity regarded the tiny girl with an expression that was both tender and wondering. “I wouldn’t have believed you could change so much, so quickly,” she whispered, not at all talking about Sunset’s regression. “But if you can keep it up, yes, the girls will like you very much indeed.” Sunset smiled in her sleep as Rarity continued to stroke her hair. Through the window, the eastern sky was beginning to brighten just slightly. Rarity saw this and smiled, letting her hand rest on Sunset’s cheek as she closed her eyes and drifted off to sleep as well.
- 1
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

A New Dawn for Sunset